New locators

classic Classic list List threaded Threaded
1 message Options
Reply | Threaded
Open this post in threaded view

New locators

Joel Hendriks

When I was checking the Dutch translations on Transifex for Zotero I
noticed some minor inconsistency with some of the translations that were
made earlier on. But I also noticed that some words could be better
translated on the CSL localization.

Right now I am discussing with Rintze about what would be the best
translation for ‘issue’ and ‘edition’. That is how I came up to this

A lot of newspapers, magazines and journals use year/number to identify
a single finished product by the creators; which can get reproduced many
times depending on the kind of material. I argued that this could be
seen as: volume/issue. Rintze argued that ‘issue’ should be called (in
dutch) ‘number’. I think there is something to say for both. So, what’s

Scenario 1:
We stick to a strict explanation like the way it is written in the
specification right now:

(container) edition holding the item (e.g. ">>>3<<<" when citing a
chapter in the >>>third<<< edition of a book)
(container) issue holding the item (e.g. ">>>5<<<" when citing a journal
article from journal volume 2, issue >>>5<<<)
(container) volume holding the item (e.g. "2" when citing a chapter from
book volume 2)

Which would also mean that the description of >>volume<< should be
altered to let it say something like it does on Wikipedia
[ (bibliography)]: “The term is also
used as an identifier for a sequence of periodicals, generally based on
a single calendar year. However, a school magazine might start each new
volume at the beginning of the academic year, or at the beginning of
each term/semester. Thus, all issues published in the Nth term or year
will be classified under the Nth volume."

Scenario 2:
We add a new >>date<< variable called >issued-year< to make a clear
distinction between >>issued<< and >issued-year<.
We add a new >>locator<<  called >number< or alter the definition of the
variable >>number<<.

What is your opinion on this?

Note, I did not write this to discuss or discredit the work of Rintze,
it is just that I think CSL can be improved by clearing this up.

With kind regards / Met vriendelijke groeten,

Joël Hendriks

Traverse 68
5361 TG  Grave (The Netherlands)
[hidden email]
(+31) 06-41397761

Learn Graph Databases - Download FREE O'Reilly Book
"Graph Databases" is the definitive new guide to graph databases and their
applications. Written by three acclaimed leaders in the field,
this first edition is now available. Download your free book today!
xbiblio-devel mailing list
[hidden email]